The EU has put a planned vote on the disputed Child Sexual Abuse Regulation (CSAR) on hold, removing it from the October 14 agenda for now.
The postponement followed Germany’s public opposition on October 7, when Berlin insisted that any form of chat monitoring must remain off-limits and said it “will not agree” to the current proposal.
At the heart of the controversy is a requirement in a Danish-drafted version of the law that would force messaging services used in Europe to scan shared URLs, images and videos for child sexual abuse material (CSAM) — even within end-to-end encrypted chats.
That proposal envisions mandatory client-side scanning, a technique that would analyze content on users’ devices before encryption, a step critics say undermines the core protections encryption provides.
Technologists and cryptographers have long argued these scanning systems are incompatible with strong end-to-end encryption and would create new vulnerabilities rather than eliminate them.
More than 500 cryptography experts signed an open letter warning the draft fails to resolve problems around encryption, mass surveillance and false positives.
Over 40 European privacy-focused tech firms have also cautioned that the rule would damage Europe’s digital sovereignty and harm secure services.
Signal’s vice-president for global affairs described the mandatory scanning as tantamount to “malware on your device,” a comparison that has been echoed across the privacy community.
The debate is not new: proposals to regulate messaging and add “chat control” measures first surfaced in EU discussions in 2022, and the issue keeps returning to lawmakers’ desks.
Germany’s refusal to back the current text appears to have denied the proposal the majority it needed this time, but stakeholders warn this is a pause, not a defeat.
Patrick Breyer, a lawyer and former MEP with the German Pirate Party, said EU governments are still refining the draft behind the scenes and preparing for further talks.
Interior ministers are due to meet again in early December (December 6–7), and those sessions are seen as a likely venue for renewed negotiations.
Some advocates hope the European Commission might withdraw the bill entirely, a drastic option that would acknowledge a political miscalculation, according to Callum Voge of the Internet Society.
Signal Foundation president Meredith Whittaker cautioned that closed-door bargaining may produce semantic changes that appear to protect privacy while eroding it in practice, and warned that any backdoor or scanning regime creates cyber‑security holes exploitable by criminals and hostile states.
European privacy-first services are coordinating resistance: several providers have warned of legal challenges, and at least one email service has said it stands ready to sue if the rules proceed.
The CSAR fight also renews broader concerns about other safety laws — like proposals that touch on online safety and age verification — which can similarly threaten end-to-end encryption if drafted without strong safeguards.
For now, secure messaging remains legally safe from this particular measure, but the underlying political and technical battle over how to balance child protection with privacy and security is far from over.
Why People Need VPN Services to Unblock Porn
People increasingly turn to VPN services to unblock porn content due to widespread geo-restrictions and censorship imposed by governments and ISPs around the world. A VPN provides users with anonymity and privacy by encrypting their internet traffic and masking their IP address, allowing them to bypass regional blocks and access adult content without surveillance or bandwidth throttling. Porn unblocked through VPN services gives users the freedom to explore content libraries from different regions while maintaining their digital privacy, especially when using potentially insecure public Wi-Fi networks.
Why Choose SafeShell VPN to Access Adult Content
If you're looking to access region-restricted content of Porn by using a Porn unblock solution, you may want to consider the SafeShell VPN, which offers comprehensive features designed specifically for privacy-conscious users. SafeShell VPN provides numerous benefits that make it an ideal choice for those wanting to unblock porn sites while maintaining their online privacy and security.
- Exceptional speed performance that eliminates buffering issues when streaming high-definition adult content, unlike many other VPNs that significantly reduce connection speeds
- Unique App Mode feature that allows users to access content from multiple regions simultaneously without constantly switching between servers
- Proprietary ShellGuard protocol that makes your VPN usage virtually undetectable, helping you bypass even the strictest content filters
- Support for up to five devices at once, covering all major platforms including Windows, macOS, iOS, Android, and various smart TV systems
- Military-grade encryption that ensures your browsing activities remain completely private from ISPs, network administrators, and potential surveillance
How to Use SafeShell VPN to Unlock Porn Sites
Accessing region-restricted content is easy with SafeShell VPN's secure connection services. Begin your unrestricted browsing experience with these simple steps:
- First, create an account on the SafeShell VPN website and select a subscription plan that matches your needs
- Download the SafeShell VPN application onto your device from their official website or your device's app store
- Install and launch the application, then log in using your newly created credentials
- Navigate to the server selection menu within the app interface
- Choose a server location in the region where your desired content is accessible
- Connect to the selected server and wait for the confirmation message
- Once connected, open your preferred browser and navigate to your desired websites
- Enjoy your content with the privacy and security that SafeShell VPN provides
